Videos

Does Jimmy Thelin deserve criticism? I The Football Show



PLZ Soccer – The Football Show

On this packed episode of The Football Show, we review a dramatic weekend of Scottish Premiership action and preview crucial midweek fixtures as the season hits its thrilling climax.

📲Download the Arnold Clark App NOW https://bit.ly/4gpXGgr
Martin O’Neill vs Gordon Strachan LIVE – Get Tickets Now: https://www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/1345290603409?aff=oddtdtcreator
Get EXCLUSIVE members only content: https://www.youtube.com/@PLZSoccer/join
SUBSCRIBE NOW: https://youtube.com/@PLZSoccer?sub_confirmation=1

📉 St Johnstone’s Survival Fight
Simo Valakari breathes new life into Saints’ battle for survival with a win over Ross County — can they complete the great escape?

🔥 Playoff Preview: Partick Thistle v Livingston
David Martindale says the playoff format “isn’t broken.” The panel debates whether the two-legged structure is fair and predicts which club will survive.

🏆 Hearts & Derek McInnes – The Perfect Fit?
Could Derek McInnes be the next man in the Tynecastle dugout? The team dissects what his arrival would mean and whether he’s taken Kilmarnock as far as he can.

🧠 Analytics in Management Decisions
How much influence do tools like Jamestown Analytics have in Scottish club decisions — and did it really pick Neil Critchley?

📝 Manager of the Year Debate
Jimmy Thelin is nominated — but should he be? The timing of the vote and Aberdeen’s inconsistency fuel heated discussion.

🔄 Rangers Rebuild
Barry Ferguson steadies the ship temporarily — but with the club in flux, the panel asks: What next? Is Leon Balogun worth another deal? Can Rangers attract the right calibre of players?

📉 VAR Outrage – Tony Docherty’s Fury
After another controversial call, the Dundee boss blasts VAR. The team examines whether refereeing tech is failing clubs at the bottom.

🥉 Race for Third & Europe
Hibs FC edge closer to clinching third. Can St Mirren or Aberdeen mount a last-minute charge?

💬 Fan Involvement:
Who finishes 11th?
Can St Johnstone escape?
Should McInnes go to Hearts?
Leave your comments below ⬇️

The Football Show Highlights:

00:00 Intro & Weekend Scottish Premiership Results
01:50 Tribute to Dave Clunie & Jim Herriot
03:45 Derek McInnes Hearts FC New Manager
05:00 Jamestown Analytics Selecting Neil Critchley
06:40 McInnes as Hearts FC manager
07:57 Jimmy Thelin Nominated Scottish Football Writers’ Manager of the Year
10:15 PLZ Premium Promo
11:30 Weekend Scottish Premiership Results Recap
12:20 Scottish Premiership Relegation Battle Analysis
14:00 Reactions from Valakari & Don Cowie – St Johnstone 2-1 Ross County
16:00 Kilmarnock 3–2 Dundee: VAR & Relegation
19:01 Tony Docherty on VAR Injustice
21:00 Dundee vs Ross County Preview
22:00 SFA VAR Debate Continues
24:45 Rangers 4–0 Aberdeen: Reaction
28:04 Barry Ferguson Post Match Interview
29:20 Rangers FC Summer Squad Rebuild Ahead
30:20 Balogun’s Future at Rangers
31:00 Rangers Takeover by 49ers Latest
32:05 Can Rangers Close the Gap With Celtic?
34:00 Jimmy Thelin Focused on League, Not Scottish Cup Final
34:50 Celtic 3–1 Hibs: Match Review
36:10 Hibs FC Transformation Praised – Especially Rocky Bushiri
37:30 Celtic FC’s Relentless Treble Pursuit
40:00 Celtic’s Summer Transfer Rumours
41:30 Who Might Celtic Sell? Hatate and Fringe Players
42:00 St Mirren’s Europa Conference League Hopes
42:54 Hearts 3–0 Motherwell: Shankland Form
45:00 Shankland’s Future Under Derek McInnes
46:15 Upcoming Events: Gordon Strachan & Peter Martin Live
47:12 Livingston vs Partick Thistle Playoff Semi-Final Preview
49:49 David Martindale Confident on Silencing Brian Graham
50:45 History of Playoff Success & Challenges
52:00 Trent Alexander-Arnold Booed by Liverpool Fans
54:00 Nottingham Forest Evangelos Marinakis Public Outburst at Manager.
55:05 Upcoming Charity Match at Ravenscraig

VISIT PLZ SOCCER HERE:

SUBSCRIBE: https://www.youtube.com/c/plzsoccer?sub_confirmation=1
FACEBOOK: https://Facebook.com/plzsoccer
X: https://twitter.com/plzsoccer
WEBSITE: https://www.plzsoccer.com

#scottishfootball #scottishpremiership #spfl #celticfc #rangersfc

Source

Similar Posts

22 thoughts on “Does Jimmy Thelin deserve criticism? I The Football Show
  1. You have to look at the season averaged out, and on that front, it's been a very good first season, for Jimmy.
    Far too many make the mistake of concentrating on our unbeaten start, and then the winless run. You can't do that. With that in mind, Should we finish 4th, it's still been an improvement on last season, which all we should've been looking for in his first season, and yet another rebuild.
    We'll see a different Dons side next season.

  2. Great show guys great talking points views opinons banter and brilliant topics and see you on the next show come on the well come on ye well make sure you like subsribe and share to the football show!!!

  3. I love Thelin, but there's still things that he does that are dumbfounding. Too much tinkering with the starting line-up and some of the substitution decisions seem a bit naive. Ok, the team is only ever going to be outside the top two, unless some serious investment comes. The squad is ok, but play the STRONGEST starting line-up please Jimmy! 🙂

  4. Jimmy Thelin is a poor manager. That woeful slump Aberdeen had while back with no wins in 10 league games or something like that should have seen him getting his marching orders. It was a pathetic run of useless form.

    He doesnt inspire, lacks any charisma, his interviews would put you in a coma.

    Celtic will adminster the coup de grace to him and the dandy dons with a 5-1 Cuo final thumping.

  5. It's quite incredible how no clubs have been able to compete with the old firm for this long. Look at what knutsen did with bodo over in norway, hes shown its still possible to build with little to no money and being reliant on a core set of attacking principles and player devolvement. Most spl clubs would rather hire old fashioned 1960s hoofball british managers though rather than hiring someone with a bit of flair with fresh ideas. Scotland is mates rates jobs for the boys, if your face fits you get jobs. Just look it boyds bum licking for mciness for the hearts job at weekend. Its everything wrong with scottish football. And im a rangers fan saying that.

  6. Aberdeen are only 3 points behind hibs but no talk of david gray shouldn't be on list as for derek macinnes what de he achieve at aberdeen I say that as a dons fan won a cup final against Inverness caley on penalties lost a cup final to St johnstone a league without rangers hearts &hibs last 2 seasons at aberdeen ee were dreadful but u media guys luv him don't get it!

  7. well done derek and killie on the win vs dundee. I think now when time comes and derek takes the hearts job, he will do it at the end of the season, and is the decent thing to do. but not till after the hearts game. He will take danny armstrong with him, why do you think danny is keeping his cards close to his chest and not signing with killie, because we know he is going with derek. People are wise and can read between all interviews from derek, danny and paul sheerin recently. In my eye he could stay at killie, and i feel he can do well AS MANAGER. But i do feel money and larger fan base is a bigger interest. so well done derek and wish you all the best for what you have done. Next new killie manager for me should be steven naismith, or stuart kettlewell. My choice would be naismith, he has got what it takes. so come on naisy come back to killie 🙂

  8. Alan Rough may not be feeling to great, but he is TOP MAN and still looks great, last spoke with him at a golf doo, in prestwick for a charity event, for bud mckee at st cuthberts golf club where he signed my vinyl record of scotland world cup squad, that small gesture and chat will always mean a lot to me, and other previous chats over the years. Cheers Roughie. Legend 🙂

  9. The seethe for anything Aberdeen is glorious from these clowns. Oh by the any chance you can give your reporters at press conferences a mic that isn't from Poundland

Comments are closed.

WP2Social Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com