The Hard Problem of Consciousness: Unraveling the Mystery of Mind – Brian Greene & Joe Rogan #1428

46 thoughts on “The Hard Problem of Consciousness: Unraveling the Mystery of Mind – Brian Greene & Joe Rogan #1428”

1. People really want to try and ask a fallacy to perpetuate this delusion of materialist ideology as somehow a foundational truth.
   As neuroscience evolves you will discover (as already has) that consciousness is the fundamental reality. Your reality is within your consciousness. If you look anywhere in reality you will create a neverending ghost chase of explanations that never concludes

2. Very well said

3. no you'll not find it..not in the brain atleast

4. We are consciousness having a human experience

5. Everything is in consciousness and i am that consciousness ❤
   Aham Brahamasmi 🔥

6. Michael Shermer would say to Brian Greene "we're talking on two different levels here"

7. He appealed to science of the gaps. "In the future this will evaporate based on new scientific evidence"

8. Promisory materialism – Swami Sarvapriyananda

9. How do partials make us… who cares

   The real tough question is, if consciousness is in the brain, why is there consciousness after brain activity stops… it’s been documented people remember things, experience things after brain function stops… how could consciousness live on at all if it’s a brain function?

10. Science can't prove consciousness because science is too materialistic. Consciousness is our connection to the soul. Dr Bruce Greyson has proved this with his extensive research into NDE's (Near Death Experiences). The stories people come back with are just unexplainable in scientific terms. Our brain is more like a unique radio reciever that picks up our unique consciousness and creates it into a conscious human experience. Many humans say that we are humans having a spiritual experience, but in truth, we are spiritual beings having a human experience with the ego being in the way of true realization.

11. That still wouldn’t answer subjective experience and qualia

12. Your approaching the question, with an answer in mind?

13. There is consciousness therefore physics. Physics of the gaps.

14. You will never find consciousness in a brain cause consciousness is an immaterial entity not a secretion from the brain. The subject of an individual is formless immaterial. If I don't experience myself as a brain then I'm not a brain. A subjective experience can only be what you experience yourself as. So if I dream that I'm a butterfly then that's what I am at the moment until I wake up. There is no subjective experience of being a brain or an up quark and a down quark.

15. Consciousness emerging from matter is only a hard problem if you have an incorrect hypothesis of the universe and are unwilling to reformulate it despite never being able to prove it.

    Matter actually 'emerges' from Consciousness does it not? Consciousness must be present for 'matter' to be observed.

    Has anyone seen matter existing outside of consciousness? No and they never will, a hopeless theory.

16. Not yet 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

17. Haha or maybe you have the wrong starting assumptions and you’ll be left behind by pioneers who reject your physicalist assumptions like Einstein left Cartesian spacetime behind.

18. We understand our environment through our senses in the first place. So to try to understand our senses with our senses creates a self-reference paradox. It’s like asking your eyeball to rotate in a way so that it’s looking directly at itself – the task is a logical impossibility, as is solving the Hard Problem.

19. Don’t think so it’s not like we’re learning more and more little by little had a brain produces consciousness we know less than they did 2000 years ago about consciousness we got more questions not less and besides all that it’s 100% certain when the brain is not functioning because the heart stopped. Consciousness still continues. We have enough gathered evidence to prove the consciousness continues, even though the heart stops so the brain could not produce consciousness.

20. Men and women brings a child same two unconscious things can begin consciousness

21. I think our definition of consciousness is too strict. If these electrons can create consciousness. Why can't say, a gas nebula in the perfect configuration, also be conscious or have properties of it?

22. Only spiritually aware people know that consciousness is fundamental. In the double-slit experiment, how can an interaction take place on the quantum level unless there was an awareness that an interaction took place? Without an awareness prior to the interaction, the interaction would have no value to observe a particle into existence. Ponder on this for example. How could the Big Bang have even happened unless there was an awareness of whatever triggered the Big Bang? Without an awareness that something was triggered, nothing would happen. How could something happen unless there was an awareness that something happened? It’s just common sense 😂

23. Even if you find that 20 billion particles arranged in a certain configuration yeild consciousness, the question still remains why that configuration yields consciousness.

24. You can't get consciousness from something that is defined in a way to have nothing to do with consciousness. Materialism had a good run, but it is over.

25. Welcome to YouTube !
    where the greatest questions are not just answered with logic but also developed into new theories.
    Great place to hit your head hard into emotional damages .

26. clearly not a biologist, or a neuro scientist. obvious why you don't understand.

27. Faith is the substance that does these things

28. Comments section is embarrassing. Now you know why the aliens won't contact us 😂

29. Yep. It's so funny to see every random schmuck acting like an expert in the comments section and commenting with full conviction 😂

30. It's more likely that Consciousness creates particles and quartz and electrons and in reality Consciousness is all that there is.

31. If we analyze what is conciousness, we might find it overated

32. Im sure theres much of computing science we havent found out. The numerically binary algorithms in the matrix that inevitably create certain anomolies that vibrate differently and self perpetuate themselves. Like codes and mathematical equations

33. If we think what it is doing is mindfulness, then we think the lights on. Physically we are how it interacts. A part of it. Are we consciousness in the universe or is the universe conscious? Horses not zebras

34. The universe it’s self is alive.

35. I know i know said CGJ
    But what it is i dont wanna know said me 2uu "GCAT" VERTICAL DOG on show 🦁👸🌪️🔑

36. The Brain has nothing to do with consciousness. Clinically dead patient sometimes have lucid experiences and can even see what is going on around them at a time when they are supposed to be dead.

37. So true. Its because there is life in everything God creates. God is the answer and without him there is no answer.

38. Why would there be a consciousness at all? Why does everything has to have a meaning?

39. He almost answers the question in a way.

40. Man cannot explain, so he says science cannot explain.Man was so vulnerable to accept his finite mind body

41. God.

42. ❤❤ SURE YOUR RIGHT.. OUR UNDERSTANDING EVOLVES JUST LIKE WE DID DO AND WILL CONTINUE TO DO 💯 ❤❤

43. The answer you are looking for is called the soul

44. We may never know oh well

45. At what length will atheist's go to say intelligent design doesn't exist.

46. Individual spirit inside the physical body.

Comments are closed.