Consciousness Videos

We’ve Been Testing For Consciousness Wrong



A Curious Birb

Professor Masanori Kohda has been studying fish for 3 decades. His groundbreaking paper in 2019 showed that fish are capable of passing the famous mirror test. But more importantly, his research shows that how we have tried to test for consciousness over the past half century may be wrong.

In this video, we look at how he came to these conclusions.

#research #science #nature #fish #animalbehavior #animalintelligence
______________________________________________________________________________________________

I post behind the scenes research and additional fun details that didn’t make it into each video on my Patreon.

This is the best way to support the research, writing and time that goes into the channel.

Thank you for watching and enjoying the videos!

Patreon: https://patreon.com/ACuriousBirb

_______________________________________________________________________________________________

Sources:

https://journals.plos.org/plosbiology/article?id=10.1371/journal.pbio.3000021 – 2019 study. (Initial evidence of passing mark test)
https://journals.plos.org/plosbiology/article?id=10.1371/journal.pbio.3001529 – 2022 study (Followup mark test with greater sample size, but also blue/green mark)
https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2208420120 – 2023 Study (Photo-recognition study)
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-024-70138-7#author-information – 2024 study (Mirror + Body size study)
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-025-25837-0?error=server_error#additional-information – 2025 Study (Rapid recognition)
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9334443/
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6304147/
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/002209658690038X

Lecture from Professor Kohda:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4DnMwVcdWh0&list=WL&index=15&t=1136s

_____________________________________________________________________________________________

This video uses images and illustrations from Wikimedia Commons, Flickr, and other Creative Commons sources.

Unless otherwise stated, all images have been cropped, zoomed, or otherwise modified for video presentation.

Full image credits (including authors, licenses, and source links) are available here:
FULL IMAGE CREDITS – https://1drv.ms/w/c/d2863ccf42cb2eac/IQBckAodttTrQIKDupj0jeiEAT7kKOrPnFib7lhin_9yi44?e=kT4DSQ

Source

Similar Posts

40 thoughts on “We’ve Been Testing For Consciousness Wrong”
  1. All sources are in the description

    There was one additional experiment I originally wrote into the video but ended up cutting for pacing as I felt the point was already made.

    It looks at whether cleaner wrasse could use what they learned from a mirror to judge their own body size before confronting another fish which was genuinely fascinating, but I felt the main video was already getting long so I decided to cut it (painfully).

    I’ve posted the deleted section on Patreon for anyone interested – https://www.patreon.com/cw/ACuriousBirb

    Don’t worry, it’s free to read. I just didn’t really have anywhere else to put it.

  2. Consciousness is almost universal in the animal kingdom.
    Consciousness is necessary to survive. Even a fly is conscious. That doesn't make it smart, however, just conscious! Consciousness is required before a will to live can exist, and without the will to live and reproduce a species would go extinct very rapidly.
    Why would anyone ever imagine small creatures are not conscious? That is truly bizarre.

  3. This is really cool and I'm not surprised. Your average pet owner understands animal cognition better than scientists. I studied animal cognition in university in the early 90s when they accepted none of this. Just reading the studies they based their beliefs on it was obvious it was all total bullshit. My cat knows she's looking at a reflection of herself in the mirror.

  4. Amazing video! Great prof. Kohda…. I always thought the mirrior test was rather shallow and naïve. It relies heavily on an animal being visual. I mean, we don't identify easily small changes to our smell either: I don't think that is the case for dogs and rats, for instance. If these animals used tests on us, humans, to see if we passed recognising small changes to our smell, they'd probably just say people are as dumb as stones…

  5. Another nail in the coffin for centuries of anthropocentric science. Time to begin with the assumption that they do have related capabilities and experiences, instead of the reverse? It gets a bit tiring to hear the mantra that humans are "unique."

  6. Some fish. Not all of them. Some fish have the intelligence of maybe a low intelligence dog. Other fish are kind of just reactionary. The ones that follow your finger, are a little brighter than the ones that don't. I have a whole tier of intelligence. It's pretty useful, too. It shows the lowest form of intelligence, and the highest in human cognition—as the last four are only found in humans, but only some humans.

  7. I think what makes humans special is our ability to reach up and realize everything around us is alive on a massive scale. Animals have proven in some ways they recognize this too. Our evolution requires us to relearn our animal ways. Like when we vocalize like our ape cousins and jump around it feels fun! We need to think about why that is.

  8. I believe all living things have conciousness.

    They all know they're alive.

    If you try to step on an ant, it goes crazy trying to get away. It knows something is trying to harm it.

    They've shown that plants "scream" when you cit them.

    They also have proven that plants being attacked or over browsed, will send out pheromones that predator insects pick up and follow back to the plant, where they attack the parasites.

    So I think everything alive has conciousness.

    Just differing levels of intelligence.

  9. Firstly, there is no 'conclusive evidence' for anything in science; science is skepticism, not a way to truth of any kind; Einstein said, one experiment can prove me wrong, but no experiment can prove me right; the universe is a big place and we can't know everything; secondly, regarding the mirror test, all it shows is that the animal associates a certain positioning of its finger with a certain position of the object (finger) it sees in the mirror; it has no idea that the mirror finger is its own or that the mark on the head in the mirror is on its head or that the mirror head is its own head or that the mirror head is even a head. The animal's movements are all just various associations; it comes to know that feeling its finger at a certain spot on its head is associated with the mirror finger on the mirror dot, that's all; which isn't to say that an animal like a chimpanzee or a gorilla or an orangutang isn't self-conscious, but its intelligence remains much more limited than a human's, e.g., just as mine is much more limited than Isaac Newton's or Albert Einstein's, e.g., so has relatively limited application.

  10. eventually we will come around to the simple fact that intelligence is what truly builds our world. animism was right, there is some type of intelligence (or you could say living information) running thru everything around us. we will have come full circle, arriving where we began–this time with more understanding.

  11. As an avid Marine hobbyist I've known this forever. Everything is conscious. I watch hermit crabs try on shells until they take one for a test drive and if they like it they move along if not try another one or go back to the one they were wearing. I watch snails cruise around in pairs occasionally cleaning each others shells, and manage the algae in the tank by methodically cleaning the algae , as if on a schedule. It's time we get off our High Horse and realize that EVERYTHING is conscious.From the atom ,to the Galaxies etc….

  12. My mom had a fish (I don’t remember what kind) in a tank on her shelf at work. Whever it was hungry, it would swim to the bottom and pick up a mouthful of pebbles and spit them at the glass until she gave it food. Absolutely amazing

  13. I'm not sure how you get hold of all the people opposing his research but i find it funny that they would rather argue what his finding results tell us isnt true and make up stuff. Like the number sample size and specially the "relatives" that one is ridiculous because it still prove their recognition 😂 omg

  14. 16:58 maybe 3 minutes? 🤔 I don't think it's at all sensible for an animal not to be able to recognise itself for several days, that'd be insanely stressful, and they'd probably just die before any experiments could occur

    Edit: damn I really overestimated by a lot xD but even people needing 20 minutes is crazy! Really cool! The fish needing just 20 minutes is some fishy genius xD.

    Good video btw, such a fascinating watch

  15. It's crazy that its taken this long for a general consensus to be built around the intelligence and sense of self animals have. It's just like how scientists say cats fail the mirror test, but officially they've only really tried the test with a mark on the cat's body. If you put a cat in front of a mirror and do something behind them that they can see in the mirror they will turn around to look at the object.

    Not to mention that anecdotally any pet owner can tell you their pet cat has personality, and a sense of self and others. It's important to not anthropomorphize but it's also important to not just throw that word around at anything that doesn't conform an animal to being a mindless creature either.

  16. I remember when there was an aquarium in a store that I went to. There was this large fish in the tank. And whenever I went to the side of the tank, this one fish would quickly swim up to me heading straight at me, before turning and slowly swimming, showing off it's pretty patterns.

    I am not sure if this must have been some sort of territorial threat display, but it was never doing it when I was looking straight at the tank, only when I went to the side.

    It felt like it was showing off, or wanting to socialize.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

WP2Social Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com