TRYBALS
Tribal people react to modern art for the first time.
Our patreon: https://www.patreon.com/TRYBALS
Buy Adnan a coffee: https://www.buymeacoffee.com/trybalseditor
Merch: https://trybals.myspreadshop.com/
The participants of this show reacted to Bob Ross and followed along his tutorial as well. They also did acrylic pouring art recently. Links to those videos:
https://youtu.be/o_bvZkoewEY
https://youtu.be/iX5b5LvbR7Q
https://youtu.be/JCkEtWkwZZQ
Follow us on:
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/Trybals-105923538317572
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/trybals_official/
Twitter: https://twitter.com/TRYBALS1
All the participants in this video are from Sindh, Pakistan.
Make sure to leave a like and valuable suggestions and please support our channel by hitting that subscribe button. Thanks for watching
#TribalPeopleTry #ModernArt #Art
Source
For the Barnett Newman (as with the Rothkos, without commenting on their value, specifically), a bad restoration was done on one, by an unqualified "conservator" who was accused of using house paint and a roller to apply. The paint and technique ruined the painting, which was originally made with a complex mix of different pigments/colours and binders (the substance that holds the pigments together. How a (good) painting looks in real life is next to impossible to truly capture in a tiny picture on a screen.
So many great insights! I love these people.
I thought someone ate the banana
Modern art is trash
Homie is right. The Jackson Pollock painting is crap and just random paint drips. Art is a joke nowadays.
Thanks for also showing the artwork of the people featured in the video. The cat was great and also the paintings are beautiful 😃
On the whole I agreed with the people & think they all showed great perception, but I was particularly impressed by Mr. Mohammad Riaz Jutt's humour and his reaction to Pollack. Very uplifting people to watch, I hope they are all blessed with health and happiness.
Not wrong there, people don't buy modern art for the art, they buy the name accusation of owning a "Jackson Pollock" or whatever else famous artist is doing the work. Course the tax evasion and money laundering are nice bonuses.
that guy callin me bro kinda throw me off 😀 also these arts , most people think they are stupied.
This makes me smile
She’s actually correct about the Barnett Newman. He covered the middle with a piece of tape.
What a pile of horse excreta….
is the name I have placed on my artwork which is three cherry's on a serving tray with an empty cup… I'll take anything over 20 million 😌
BRO is just a mess with paint splashed everywhere 🤣
You are wise souls. Blessings to you all!
The Jackson Pollock painting looks like a battelfield for me
Like a wave of people with weapons in hands
I think you could try showing them art from The Renaissance era and compare it to modern art and see what they say.I think me and them will agree that the art from The Renaissance era is better than modern day art.
One potential argument for contemporary I.e. modern art against realism- if you take the figurative artwork to it's extreme meaning it looks the same as the real object, why not take a photo? 'Modern' art can be what you get when people want to depict beyond the direct experienced reality. How to show depression, elation etc. without drawing a sad face. That's where the strengths of non-representative art can come to play. Also seeing some works in person helps due to size and being able to see brushstrokes etc. Saying that, some of it's shit xD
“He should know that banana is fresh, it will rot in no time. I would get an unripe green one, it would last twice as long”. 😂
Mohammad is the best. His observations are remarkable. Always. Just think what he might have done with the right opportunity. That isn't meant to demean what he has done but it seems to be such a loss for the greater good.
"It's just a mess made with paint everywhere." No better analysis of modern "art" has ever been given.
“I am ready to negotiate further.” – laughed my ass off. Well said, sir!
In my Western opinion I feel "Modern Art" is simply rubbish❗Something like Bob Ross paints is far more interesting. Just my opinion. I have to agree when I hear Parvati say "did the artist get paid for this"❓🤣 A hundred and twenty thousand dollars is a disgusting amount of money for such rubbish. When these people work so hard, and yet don't receive anywhere near that amount of money in a lifetime❗This doesn't make any sense at all.
"id use a green banana and prolong its shelf life" hahahahahahaha i love that guys humour. not paid the trybals a visit for a while so enjoying having an hour catching up with our pakistani bros n sisters
Smart people. Reminds me of the little boy who outed the king and said he had no clothes on. The Emperor's New Clothes…NOT! Wonderful reactions, so smart so real. God bless them!
You should have them react to Karl Rock.
i'm sure many people who subscribe to this channel would buy something Parvarti would paint without a doubt
money laundering. yes, like hunter biden's "art".
overall i think money paid for most modern "art" is sickening. just sickening. idiots.
Muhammad Riaz interpretation of that Jackson Pollock painting was extremely impressive! It reflects upon him as having a very deep artistic soul. I never would have seen that in that painting but I did after he spoke on it! I am so moved by all of these people's input on different songs, subjects, art etc. Each of them brings something different to each video and reveals, through their comments, how very different they are even though they come from the same places, religions, ethnic group, and lifestyle. As the same as they are, they are equally very different from each other. This is what I find so beautiful about humans. We are All One race of humanity with many many different ethnicities. Within those very different ethnicities, as different as they are, we are still the same in many ways because we are all part of the human race. I love watching these videos because I learned to see the world through different eyes in each one
Agha Mohammad was hilarious! He was also very deep when discussing the Pollock. I also loved when Parvati Khanoom asked what you would do with it when you bought it.
That's interesting. You can also show them Velazquez and Goya paintings, both Spanish painters and among the best of all time.
I think modern art is one of the stupidest ideas that has ever been conceived. Certainly some of the pieces are good, but when I see some of the simplistic things such as I'm seeing here, I can't help but thinking that money could have been better spent. People are ridiculous.
"Today a famous person could sell anything."
Oh, if he only knew what "famous" people are selling…
I also share the sentiment of not understanding most modern art, so I appreciate their reactions and opinions.
(I do like pour paintings though, there is some skill to it– knowing which colors to put, where and how to put them.)
I have studied art and art history, the modern vs. classical painting is an age old debate. The simple color block paintings leave me cold, but sell due to the fame of the artist. There is passion in Pollocks work, as can be found in many examples of abstract art. I've painted them and recently got into digital art. I've been happy for the most part with my efforts…but I'm not famous
I like Michelangelo's (a famous sculptor) quote about art. "The sculpture is already complete within the marble block, before I start my work. It is already there, I just have to chisel away the superfluous material." At the begining everyone said something that made me smile, their description of art did not include themselves or nature. Regardless of the skill and technique that may be involved, are we not art as well? Aren't you? What about a long walk? Or marriage? Maybe laughter? I wonder what laughter looks like to you if you could not draw or paint a face laughing. Would you show me a sun? Maybe a bubbling stream?
Art is in everything, even when you look at a piece of paper painted a single color and think to yourself "this cannot be art" because you look at it and are responding to it. To me, art is the space between you and the painting. It is created not with paint or marble but through the connectivity between. Love is art. Watching your videos, hearing your words, learning from you, crying with you, feeling with you, is art.
I go to a lot of art museums and visit the ones near me very often. My favorite is the sculptures and photography. Especially the silver gelatin prints and the abstract or modern art sculptures. I always look at them and feel something and then I ask myself why. Why does this bother me? Why does this make me smile? Why do I feel relieved when I look from this angle but not the other? I don't know if this will help at all but I thought maybe, since you are always sharing experiences and wisdom with me that I could share some of my own with you. And maybe, there's art in this too.
If the right people see this,their paintings will sell for a fortune!! Hahaha I love these guys
I prefer paintings and sculptures from rural communities. They tend to capture their scenery, culture, and philosophies in more meaningful ways.
Showing those Rothko paintings on a computer screen is missing the point – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1v1mBepDlOw – Talking about the absurdity of prices for art is a totally different subject and should not be mixed up with what those artists and their work was about! …I really like your channel but this was a missed opportunity to talk about what (abstract) art has to offer historically, philosophically, psychologically. You were presenting this art without any explanation or context…and you usually do that with other stuff that you present…why not this time? – It's almost like you're WORSHIPPING pop culture and dismissing anything that goes beyond mainstream notions of art.
The same reactions to these insanely high prices for modern art even in the West
The man is correct when he sees people tied up in wires. The artist was a speck in the corner.
Me parto de risa porque pienso como ellos que está lleno de imposturas y sinsentidos.
Can you show them picasso, salvador dali, van gogh and more art maybe. love their ideas so much
I am way late on commenting here, but even without knowing who Jackson Pollack was (and opinions will always be divided on his work) they realized how it was light years ahead of sticking a banana on a wall or doing two-tone work on a canvas. There's not necessarily a meaning behind any of it, but Pollack's work contains so much energy that one can just look at it and follow the different lines and everything. The trick the art teacher played says less about Pollack and more about people's desire to fit in rather than raise their hand and say, "That doesn't look a thing like a Pollack painting." By the way, Mukhtiar's (hope I got that right) painting based on Cyndi Lauper was great, and better than most of the "professionals" shown here. The colors as the seeming spiral motion caught my eye before I heard what it was supposed to be. He has some real talent, as do some of the others. It's said that more people buy art for the name and investment potential rather than to actually support and reward talent. And, before anyone asks, I'm sitting in a room full of local stuff (including paintings made by my great-grandmother) that I think are some of the best works I've seen and have helped inspire my photography.
I think some modern art is just a money laundering scheme.
todas las personas de la tierra estamos de acuerdo, esto no es arte esto es una estafa